Complaints Policy

Economic Affairs, Quarterly Journal of Economics is committed to maintaining high standards of academic integrity, transparency, fairness, and professional conduct. The journal welcomes complaints relating to the editorial process, publication ethics, reviewer conduct, authorship, conflicts of interest, and other matters associated with the publication of scholarly work.

The journal handles all complaints seriously, confidentially, impartially, and in a timely manner.

1. Scope of the Policy

This policy applies to complaints concerning, but not limited to:

  • Editorial decisions and editorial processes;
  • Delays in manuscript processing or publication;
  • Reviewer conduct or inappropriate peer-review practices;
  • Authorship and contributorship disputes;
  • Plagiarism, duplicate publication, or redundant publication;
  • Fabrication, falsification, or other forms of research misconduct;
  • Undisclosed conflicts of interest;
  • Ethical concerns relating to research involving human participants or animals;
  • Misuse of confidential information;
  • Allegations of bias, discrimination, harassment, or inappropriate conduct;
  • Errors or inaccuracies in published articles;
  • Concerns regarding retractions, corrections, or expressions of concern; and
  • Other matters relating to publication ethics or journal procedures.

2. Principles for Handling Complaints

All complaints will be handled according to the following principles:

  • Confidentiality: Information relating to a complaint will be shared only with individuals who need it for the purpose of investigation and resolution.
  • Impartiality: Complaints will be assessed objectively and without discrimination.
  • Fairness: All relevant parties will have a reasonable opportunity to provide information or respond to allegations.
  • Independence: Where a complaint concerns a member of the editorial team, the matter will, where appropriate, be referred to an independent editor or another appropriate authority who is not involved in the complaint.
  • Timeliness: The journal will endeavour to acknowledge and investigate complaints as promptly as reasonably possible.
  • No retaliation: The journal will not tolerate retaliation against individuals who raise complaints in good faith.

3. How to Submit a Complaint

Complaints should be submitted in writing to the journal's editorial office or email us at editor@economicaffairs.co.in.

A complaint should, where possible, include:

  • The complainant's name and contact information;
  • Manuscript title and manuscript/article identification number, if applicable;
  • A clear description of the complaint;
  • Relevant dates and details;
  • Supporting documents or evidence, where available; and
  • The specific resolution or action being requested, where appropriate.

Complaints should be submitted through the journal's official editorial contact channel.

The journal may request additional information or documentation when necessary to investigate the matter.

4. Acknowledgement of Complaints

The journal will acknowledge receipt of a complaint as soon as reasonably practicable.

The complainant will be informed, where appropriate, that the matter is being investigated. Because confidentiality obligations may apply, the journal may not be able to disclose all details of an investigation or the actions taken in relation to another individual.

5. Investigation and Resolution

The complaint will initially be reviewed by the appropriate member of the editorial team.

Depending on the nature and seriousness of the complaint, the journal may:

  • Review the relevant manuscript, article, editorial records, peer-review reports, and correspondence;
  • Seek information from authors, reviewers, editors, institutions, or other relevant parties;
  • Consult independent experts where appropriate;
  • Refer matters involving potential research misconduct to the relevant author's institution or responsible authority;
  • Consult recognized publication-ethics guidance;
  • Correct the published record where an error is established; or
  • Take other appropriate action based on the findings.

The journal will not make conclusions of research misconduct solely on the basis of an allegation. Appropriate evidence and, where necessary, institutional or regulatory processes will be considered.

6. Complaints Concerning Editorial Decisions

Editorial decisions are normally based on the manuscript's scholarly quality, relevance, originality, methodological soundness, ethical compliance, and suitability for the journal.

A disagreement with an editorial decision does not, by itself, constitute an ethical complaint.

Authors who believe that an editorial decision resulted from a factual error, procedural irregularity, undisclosed conflict of interest, or other substantive concern may submit a reasoned appeal or complaint.

The journal may reconsider a decision where there is substantial evidence that the decision was affected by an error or inappropriate process.

7. Complaints Concerning Peer Reviewers

Concerns regarding reviewer conduct, including inappropriate comments, conflicts of interest, breaches of confidentiality, or misuse of manuscript information, will be investigated where sufficient information is provided.

Where a reviewer is found to have breached the journal's ethical or confidentiality requirements, the journal may take appropriate action, including removal of the reviewer from the journal's reviewer database.

8. Authorship and Contributorship Disputes

The journal expects all authors to agree on authorship and contributorship before submission.

The journal generally will not adjudicate disputes concerning authorship between individuals. Where an authorship dispute arises, the journal may request that the authors resolve the matter through their institution or another appropriate authority.

Where necessary, publication or editorial action may be taken based on the findings or recommendations of the relevant institution.

9. Research and Publication Misconduct

Allegations of plagiarism, fabrication, falsification, duplicate publication, manipulation of peer review, unethical research practices, or other serious misconduct will be investigated in accordance with applicable publication-ethics principles.

Where appropriate, the journal may:

  • Request an explanation or supporting evidence from the authors;
  • Contact the relevant institution or research organization;
  • Correct, retract, or withdraw an article;
  • Publish an expression of concern; or
  • Take other appropriate editorial action.

10. Corrections, Retractions and Expressions of Concern

When a published article contains a significant error or when concerns regarding the reliability or integrity of the published record are substantiated, the journal may publish a correction, retraction, expression of concern, or other appropriate notice.

The journal aims to maintain the integrity and transparency of the scholarly record.

11. Appeals

If a complainant believes that a complaint has not been handled appropriately, they may submit a written appeal explaining the basis for the appeal to the editor-in-chief directly.

An appeal should provide new information, identify a procedural concern, or explain why the original response was inadequate. Repeated appeals without new substantive information may not be considered.

Where appropriate, an appeal will be reviewed by an editor or responsible authority who was not directly involved in the original decision.

12. External Ethical Guidance

The journal is guided by recognized principles of publication ethics and may consult relevant guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) when handling complaints and allegations concerning publication ethics.

Official COPE website and guidance: https://publicationethics.org/

The journal may also refer to other applicable ethical and professional standards, including relevant guidance from organizations such as WAME (https://wame.org/) and applicable institutional, national, and international regulations.

13. Confidentiality and Data Protection

The journal will treat complaint-related information confidentially and will process personal information in accordance with applicable data-protection and privacy requirements.

Information will be disclosed only where necessary for the investigation, where required by law or regulation, or where disclosure is otherwise appropriate to protect the integrity of the scholarly record.

14. Anonymous Complaints

The journal may consider anonymous complaints where sufficient information or evidence is provided to permit a meaningful investigation.

However, the journal may be unable to investigate or respond fully where the identity of the complainant is necessary to establish the facts.

15. Good-Faith Complaints

The journal encourages individuals to raise legitimate concerns in good faith.

Complaints should be factual, specific, and supported by evidence where possible. The journal reserves the right to take appropriate action where complaints are demonstrably malicious, abusive, threatening, discriminatory, or intended to improperly interfere with the editorial process.

16. Contact

Complaints should be submitted to:

Editorial Office
Economic Affairs, Quarterly Journal of Economics
Email: editor@economicaffairs.co.in

Please include “Complaint – Publication Ethics” in the subject line of the email.

The journal will acknowledge the complaint and communicate the outcome or next appropriate step where it is reasonably possible to do so.

Policy Review

This Complaints Policy will be reviewed periodically and updated when necessary to reflect changes in publication-ethics standards, applicable regulations, and journal procedures.

Economic Affairs, Quarterly Journal of Economics| In Association with AESSRA

147949948 - Visitors since February 20, 2019